The Jacksonville City Council chambers. | City of Jacksonville photo

Jacksonville’s elected leaders are staring down a $300 million loss in property-tax revenue over the next two years, a reckoning that has no precedent in the city’s modern history. The decline, attributable to a sweeping tax cut that Florida voters approved in November, could leave almost no city service, including public safety, immune to cuts.

โ€œThe voters have spoken,โ€ City Council President Nick Howland said. โ€œThey want property tax relief. They expect core services to be protected, and they’re asking for a government that lives within its means.โ€

Jacksonville’s budget has ballooned in the past several years, enjoying pandemic-era federal relief money and rising property values, increasing half a billion dollars since Mayor Donna Deegan took office. 

“That’s the biggest increase in history because property values went up, and that’s what the legislature was reacting to is in the wealthier, larger counties, huge increases in tax revenue,โ€ former Mayor John Delaney said. โ€œElected officials have a habit of spending whatever revenue comes in the door.”

But those federal dollars have dwindled, and the passage of Amendment 3, which raises the homestead exemption on non-school property taxes to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028,ย leaves Jacksonville with the largest year-over-year decline in revenue among Floridaโ€™s cities, according to one policy groupโ€™s analysis. Now, the city faces a period of immense uncertainty that could impact high-profile projects, like a proposed new jail.

Statewide, nearly 62% voted to increase the homestead exemption, clearing the 60% threshold required for passage. In Duval, 57% of voters said yes on their ballots earlier this month.

Deegan’s administration has said since the tax-relief measure passed that it would not target public safety spending for cuts, but the City Council’s auditor said leaving those giant costs untouched in the future would be difficult given the degree of the belt tightening city officials will have to begin next year.

Public safety costs โ€“ including the Jacksonville Sheriffโ€™s Office, Jacksonville Fire and Rescue Department, and the pension debt for the departments โ€“ make up more than 63% of the city’s $2 billion general fund. 

That spending does not include the cost of juvenile-justice diversion programs and other services the city provides that are also left vulnerable.

Deegan and her allies declined to cut down on Jacksonvilleโ€™s budget this year, arguing that Amendment 3 may not pass and, even if it did, that they wanted to prioritize delivering strong city services for the next year. The mayor has also indicated her investment in downtown development will continue, despite an increasingly high price to taxpayers.

The finance committee debated this year whether to pare down the Kids Hope Alliance’s $60 million budget, signaling it may bear the brunt of next yearโ€™s financial insecurity. Unlike independent, special taxing agencies in other Florida counties that provide childrenโ€™s services, KHA is funded through the city budget and so is at the mercy of city council members.

The Deegan administration has already performed hypothetical โ€œfinancial exercisesโ€ of what a 10% reduction in funding would look like for KHA, her administration said. Still, concrete cuts will not materialize until the spring of next year as the mayorโ€™s office and city council gain a better sense of the cityโ€™s revenue generated from other streams outside of property taxes.ย 

โ€œIn May, we will submit a balanced budget and still do the priorities of the mayor and the priorities of the council, just not to the extent, probably, that we’ve been able to do in the past,โ€ said Mike Weinstein, the mayorโ€™s chief administrative officer.

Funds for eviction diversion, telehealth, and the cityโ€™s cultural council were already slashed in this yearโ€™s budget, cuts that were triggered by Amendment 3โ€™s passage, and similar initiatives will likely be cut down next year, including the cityโ€™s public service grant program.

โ€œThe only thing that’s off the table is reducing public safety,โ€ Weinstein said. โ€œPublic safety will have some impact, but they will continue to grow to the extent that they can. It’s the number one priority.โ€

โ€˜KHA is public safetyโ€™

While city officials view spending on police and fire as a top priority ahead of the ramifications of Amendment 3, the reach of public safety expands far beyond those two agencies. 

โ€œAll of the state attorneys and sheriffs have long felt prevention would save money over time. If you can keep people away from crime, you don’t need as many jail beds. And you don’t tie up as much court time,โ€ said Delaney, who is also a former state prosecutor.

In partnership with local organizations and state agencies, KHA funds juvenile justice programs like teen court. Investment from both federal grants and matched dollars by the city allows KHA to have a broadened impact on the cityโ€™s most vulnerable kids.

โ€œIf KHA is cut, crime goes up every time,โ€ Council Member Matt Carlucci said. โ€œKHA is a part of public safety.โ€

In addition to supporting public safety, KHA provides programs ranging from before and after-school care to summer camps and initiatives to meet familiesโ€™ nutritional needs. These programs, often housed within public schools, supplement the work of school districts. Without those programs to support students in need, Duval County Public Schools expect to feel the impact of slashed funding for KHA too.

Duval schools, which are already eating budget cuts because of record low enrollment, will not be able to make up for cuts to KHA. Costs for running programs like summer camps could be passed on to families in the form of heavier fees. 

Efforts to form a childrenโ€™s services council, a special taxing district that manages spending on programs for kids, began in 1990 when then-State Attorney Ed Austin rallied support for a separate property tax. 

โ€œJacksonville has got an earned reputation of being anti-tax, but whenever a proposalโ€™s been put before the voters, they’ve always supported it other than in 1990,โ€ Delaney said.

The tax that would have insulated the Kids Hope Alliance โ€” formerly known as the Jacksonville Childrenโ€™s Commission โ€” from general fund budget constraints narrowly failed without the backing of former Mayor Tommy Hazouri.

โ€œWhat the tax primarily did, rather than create a massive new city bureaucracy, is supplement existing programs so that [the Commission] could reach more children,โ€ Delaney said.

40 new police officers hired with federal funding

City auditors are working on new projections since Amendment 3 passed, but the total revenue decrease could be more than $370 million, according to the Florida Policy Institute, which lists Jacksonville as the single most financially affected city.

Ron Salem, a previous City Council president who is finishing his term in July, said he advocated for $100 million to be put in the reserves this year to prepare for the reality of Amendment 3. 

โ€œAny private business would have been preparing for this,โ€ Salem said in an interview. โ€œOther counties prepared. Other cities prepared. We did not, and I think it’s incumbent upon the mayor to lead.โ€

Howland praised this yearโ€™s budget process for keeping spending flat year-to-year for the first time since 2017, saying โ€œwe conducted one of the most thorough budget reviews in council history, challenging every dollar.โ€ 

But not much was effectively stocked in the reserves, with the council approving 99% of Deeganโ€™s budget and instead putting any savings towards $26 million for police and fire capital projects like tenant and leasehold improvements for JSOโ€™s new headquarters at the Florida Blue building, JSOโ€™s warehouse consolidation, and to purchase a carbon dioxide removal system for the fire department.

JSO is also in the early planning stages for moving Duval County jail out of downtown to a to-be-determined site. The consultant contract for the first phase has already cost the city $750,000. 

After Amendment 3 passed, JSO announced a three-year, $73 million federal grant to improve the departmentโ€™s technology capabilities and hire 40 new officers. Those 40 positions, however, and their retirement costs, will have to be funded by the cityโ€™s dwindling operating funds for years to come after that grant is up.

On top of public safetyโ€™s billion-dollar budget, some of the cityโ€™s line items cannot be skipped or cut down next year, including debt service and the police and fire pension debt. This fall, the city budgeted $120 million for debt service and a record $209 million payment to the pension debt for police and fire. 

Long term, however, Amendment 3 could slow or completely halt capital investment in Jacksonville, said Bill Gulliford, a former City Council president and mayor of Atlantic Beach.  

โ€œYou stop making significant capital improvements or even repairs to capital assets, and then down the road you find yourself 10 years out, you find yourself in a bit of a squeeze,โ€ he told the Trib.

Gulliford said small cities in Duval County like Atlantic Beach and Jacksonville Beach will likely survive the major change in tax revenue from Amendment 3 due to thriving commercial districts.     Neptune Beach, however, is primarily residential and could be more vulnerable.

โ€œThey can probably get through the next five years or so, but after that, it might get really tight,โ€ Gulliford said. โ€œYou may see the state step in and provide another funding source for small communities. We don’t know what might transpire.โ€

With such a big drop in the cityโ€™s revenue, Jacksonville could explore new revenue options โ€” like increasing the franchise fee on customerโ€™s JEA bills, or increasing the garbage fee โ€” to get out of a tough financial spot, though neither of those options, even together, would close the $300 million hole.

The mayorโ€™s office said itโ€™s not considering increasing fees or taxes to raise revenue. Increasing a sales tax could not appear on the ballot until 2028,, the auditor said, and other tax hikes seem “disingenuous” to the spirit of Amendment 3, Carlucci said. 

Either way, a new revenue stream large enough to alleviate the effects of Amendment 3 before next yearโ€™s budget is unlikely, meaning residents will likely see real cuts to KHA, libraries, and other city services starting next fall.

Carlucci, who agreed public safety should not be cut, called Amendment 3 โ€œa poison pill.โ€

โ€œWe should not do any tax increase this year or next year,โ€ he said. โ€œHonor what the taxpayers wanted and see how they like it.โ€

Molly Farrar is a Report for America corps member and the Florida Tribโ€™s Jacksonville municipal watchdog reporter. She can be reached at molly.farrar@floridatrib.org.

Trinity Webster-Bass covers education for The Florida Trib. You can reach her at trinity.webster-bass@floridatrib.org.

Molly Farrar covers accountability and policy in the consolidated city-county government of Jacksonville for The Florida Trib. Before joining us as a Report for America corps member, Farrar worked as a staff writer for Boston.com with the Boston Globe, WHDH Channel 7, and as a freelance reporter in the Greater Boston area covering local politics. Her news and transportation reporting won regional awards, and Farrar was selected as a First Amendment Institute Fellow with the New England First Amendment Coalition. Her investigative work on criminal justice and prisons was published in GBH News and The Intercept. Her stories have also appeared in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch and The Boston Globe. Farrar graduated from Boston University with a degree in journalism and cello performance, where she also served as editor-in-chief of the Daily Free Press, the independent student newspaper. You can reach Molly at molly.farrar@floridatrib.org.

Trinity Webster-Bass covers education for The Florida Trib. A recent Howard University graduate, she served as president of the Ida B. Wells Society for Investigative Reporting, reported for The Hilltop, and covered the 2024 Democratic National Convention and local politics for Howard University News Service.

She began her career interning at WJCT 89.9 FM in Jacksonville before joining The Washington Post as an audio intern, where she produced an investigative story on police use of AI. Most recently, Trinity interned at The New York Times through the Ida B. Wells Society, reporting on cannabis legislation and pitfalls in the organ donation process.

She received awards from the White House Correspondents' Association, the Society of Professional Journalists, and the National Association of Black Journalists for her work.

You can reach Trinity at trinity.webster-bass@floridatrib.org