Former JEA CEO Aaron Zahn walks out of the Bryan Simpson United States courthouse in downtown Jacksonville after being convicted in federal court of conspiracy and wire fraud on Friday, March 15, 2024. | Will Brown, Jacksonville Today

Sitting in a South Carolina prison in May, former JEA CEO Aaron Zahn lashed out at multiple people – including current and former Jacksonville officials – he believed were responsible for his dramatic downfall years ago, ultimately ending in federal conspiracy and wire fraud convictions and a four-year sentence. His remarks, part of a deposition related to a long-running civil dispute, are his first publicly reported comments in years, revealing a former utility executive who remains defiant about his role in one of the largest political scandals in Jacksonville’s history and bitter about the fallout.

“And I’ll go back and I’ll sleep in my steel bunk and you can go home to your family,” Zahn told an attorney representing JEA at the end of the four-hour long interview, the details of which have never been previously reported.

The transcript was part of a large batch of documents provided to The Florida Trib as part of a public-records request. Zahn’s original employment contract contained a clause allowing him to challenge his nearly seven-year-old firing in arbitration. Although ordinarily confidential, a Duval County judge ruled years ago that his arbitration proceedings were subject to Florida’s broad Sunshine Law. 

The interview, taken at the federal prison FCI Edgefield, offers the most detailed look into Zahn’s thinking since his termination from JEA in 2020, after which he’s made few public statements. The passage of time hasn’t softened Zahn’s long-held view, and apparent frustration, that he fell victim to a cabal of Jacksonville insiders. At one point during the deposition, Zahn directly addressed the attorney interviewing him, Lee Wedekind, who represents JEA. “And I had people like you, and I don’t know why, trying to create problems that never existed and harm me and my family …,” Zahn told Wedekind.

In the interview, Zahn argued again and again he was the “scapegoat” at the center of a high-level conspiracy, echoing arguments his criminal attorneys made during his trial several years ago, ultimately unsuccessfully. 

In 2018, Zahn took over running JEA, Jacksonville’s city-owned electric, water and sewer utility. The defining project of his tenure was a botched attempt to sell the public utility – one of the largest agencies of its kind in the United States – to a private operator. That effort attracted numerous multi-billion-dollar bids, the highest of which came from Florida Power & Light, whose parent company is currently trying to acquire Dominion Energy in Virginia. 

Zahn’s privatization effort also attracted immense public scrutiny, particularly after revelations that he and his top executives had developed a plan to pocket millions of dollars in proceeds if JEA had been sold – a scheme that later became the centerpiece of a federal prosecution against Zahn.

During the May interview, Zahn blamed his troubles on having upset powerful forces, including labor unions that represented JEA employees, and corporations, including Georgia-based Southern Co., which co-owned an over-budget nuclear power project Zahn had sought to offload from JEA’s financial obligations. 

Zahn and his civil attorneys have long argued that JEA’s board of directors and city lawyers violated his then-employment contract by firing him for cause in early 2020. 

In September, a private arbitrator agreed with Zahn, finding that JEA botched the process of terminating him and as a result could owe him damages. That decision, a remarkable breakthrough for Zahn, did not mention the high-profile controversies that had accumulated during Zahn’s time running JEA, nor his later conviction and prison sentence.

In May, appearing involuntarily for a deposition, Zahn claimed that the city’s Office of General Counsel, then led by Jason Gabriel, never tried to negotiate an amicable separation between Zahn and JEA in good faith as public criticism mounted in late 2019 and early 2020 around Zahn’s privatization push. He said former Jacksonville Mayor Lenny Curry “had lost complete confidence” in Gabriel and the OGC and accused them of trying to find a fall guy. He also accused the office of deleting numerous records related to both his termination from JEA and around efforts to sell the utility.

Gabriel, who testified for the federal government during Zahn’s trial, said in a statement Thursday evening that a jury “already rejected Mr. Zahn’s claim that he was a scapegoat.”

“The record speaks for itself,” Gabriel said. “I’m a member of the Florida Bar, he’s a convicted felon.”

Curry also denied having ever lost faith in Gabriel’s leadership of OGC. “Jason’s my friend,” Curry said. “I still work with him. That speaks for itself.”

Zahn’s attorney did not immediately respond to a request for comment Thursday night.

Zahn had particular scorn for April Green, the chair of the JEA board during his final months as CEO. Although once supportive, Green eventually soured on Zahn’s leadership and led an effort to oust him for cause. She was also a witness for federal prosecutors during Zahn’s trial. 

Zahn said in May that during a heated phone call in late 2019, Green told him she would “hurt myself and my family” if he did not resign as CEO.

“I’ve lost my entire family. I’ve lost my career. I’ve lost almost all of my financial assets,” Zahn testified at the deposition. “My children have been harmed. I had to relocate from a city that I loved. She did a lot of damage, yes. She executed on her threat.”

Green didn’t respond to a request for comment Thursday night. But in her own deposition in June, when an attorney asked if she recalled an exchange like that, she said, “Absolutely not.”

Zahn’s frustrations didn’t end with Green. He also laid blame at the feet of her husband, Eric Green, the CEO of the Jacksonville Port Authority, whom he cast as one of the “gravy train of people that were making lots of money out of the status quo,” which Zahn saw himself as disrupting. He said Eric Green was interested in using JEA money to support a port project. 

Eric Green didn’t respond to a request for comment Thursday night. In her deposition, April described her and her husband’s interactions with Zahn – during a dinner at a restaurant in Atlantic Beach – to have been friendly. 

Whether Zahn’s comments about April Green left an impression on the arbitrator in his civil case is unclear. But without naming Green, the arbitrator was critical of her when ruling in Zahn’s favor, casting city officials as having caved to public pressure.

Zahn also accused Matrix LLC, an Alabama consulting firm, of coordinating a project to ruin him on behalf of Southern Co., a longtime and known client of Matrix’s that had been frustrated by Zahn’s efforts to distance JEA from a nuclear power project at Plant Vogtle in Georgia.

He said Matrix’s effort, called “bury Zahn,” was carried out in part through Jacksonville’s daily newspaper and its reporters, including Nate Monroe, a co-author of this report and executive editor of The Trib.

Zahn has long been critical of the Florida Times-Union’s coverage of his tenure, widely recognized as having played a leading role in halting the JEA privatization effort.

Zahn was found guilty of wire fraud and conspiracy after a month-long trial, reporting to prison for his four-year sentence in 2024. Currently, federal records indicate he’s reported to a halfway house in Orlando.

In a 36-page decision issued in September, the arbitrator, Leslie W. Langbein, found that Zahn may be owed damages because, instead of firing Zahn without cause, as the board had initially agreed to in December 2019 during a frenzied effort to tamp down public criticism of the agency, city attorneys improperly “favored a course of action that yielded to … public clamor and political pressure demanding Zahn’s termination with cause.”

It’s not clear when the arbitrator will decide what potential damages and other fees JEA owes Zahn.

Nate Monroe is Executive Editor of The Florida Trib.

Molly Farrar is a Report for America corps member and the Florida Trib’s Jacksonville municipal watchdog reporter. She can be reached at molly.farrar@floridatrib.org.

Nate Monroe is Executive Editor of The Florida Trib. He has been a journalist in the Southeast for the past 15 years. Most recently, he wrote a column about Florida for the USA Today Network. He was previously a metro columnist, beat reporter and investigative reporter for the Florida Times-Union in Jacksonville, where he focused on covering the largest municipal government in Florida. Prior to arriving in Jacksonville in 2013, Nate was a reporter for newspapers in the Florida Panhandle and South Louisiana.

Nate's work has won local, state and national awards and led to federal convictions, voter-led reforms, and other significant impacts.

You can reach him at nate.monroe@floridatrib.org.

Molly Farrar covers accountability and policy in the consolidated city-county government of Jacksonville for The Florida Trib. Before joining us as a Report for America corps member, Farrar worked as a staff writer for Boston.com with the Boston Globe, WHDH Channel 7, and as a freelance reporter in the Greater Boston area covering local politics. Her news and transportation reporting won regional awards, and Farrar was selected as a First Amendment Institute Fellow with the New England First Amendment Coalition. Her investigative work on criminal justice and prisons was published in GBH News and The Intercept. Her stories have also appeared in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch and The Boston Globe. Farrar graduated from Boston University with a degree in journalism and cello performance, where she also served as editor-in-chief of the Daily Free Press, the independent student newspaper. You can reach Molly at molly.farrar@floridatrib.org.