Mountainous piles of coal ash sit at the Keystone port terminal. (Photo courtesy of the City of Jacksonville)

A mountain of powdery gray coal ash rises between the St. Johns River and the low-slung homes of Jacksonville’s Talleyrand neighborhood. It sits, exposed to the wind and rain, on a dusty lot in the privately owned Keystone port terminal.

The ash won’t stay put. Neighbors say it blows over their homes, coating their cars and creeping in through their windows. Environmentalists say it washes away with the rain, seeping into the groundwater and the river. The city of Jacksonville and the state of Florida say Keystone’s shoddily contained ash piles may violate state and local law and put public health and the environment at risk.

The ash has little to do with the Jacksonville residents who may inhale it. It comes from a coal-fired power plant in Puerto Rico, and it’s destined for a landfill in Georgia. Keystone simply collects a check for unloading thousands of tons of ash from Caribbean barges and loading it onto trucks headed for the Georgia dump. In the past five years, Jacksonville has been a temporary holding pen for more than one million tons of someone else’s ash.

“I don’t know of any other community accepting this amount of coal ash from a different community,” said Lisa Rinaman, who heads St. Johns Riverkeeper, an environmental nonprofit. “We’re importing this pollution.”

Now, Jacksonville Mayor Donna Deegan says the ash piles have to go. On Nov. 17, Deegan ordered Keystone to stop receiving ash and get rid of its existing ash by Jan. 1, or else face fines of up to $2,000 per day. Although Keystone has been receiving and storing coal ash since at least 2017, Deegan said the city just realized Keystone never had the proper permits.

“This operation has never been reviewed by the city as required by local ordinance code,” Deegan said at a news conference.

Piles of powdery cement, gypsum, coal ash, and other materials rise above the fence surrounding the Keystone terminal. (Photo by Nicolás Rivero) Credit: Nicolás Rivero / The Florida Trib

Keystone, a Florida corporation registered to Tom Scholl, who has also run coal mines in West Virginia with a troubled record of environmental violations, didn’t respond to an interview request or emailed questions. The company has the option to fight Deegan’s order in court, and it can still apply for a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity, the key local authorization that Deegan says Keystone is missing.

Keystone faces a separate lawsuit filed in August on behalf of St. Johns Riverkeeper, which alleges the company is breaking the federal Clean Water Act and the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, which regulates waste disposal.

“The wanton disregard for the health of our people and the health of our river led me to take action,” said John November, the attorney who filed the lawsuit and the executive director of the Public Trust for Conservation, a Jacksonville Beach-based environmental law nonprofit. “This stuff is so harmful that it’s simply not worth the risk.”

Coal naturally contains trace amounts of toxic elements such as chromium, arsenic, and mercury, according to the U.S. Geological Survey. When power plants burn coal, these toxins get concentrated in the ash that’s left behind. Toxins aside, the tiniest particles in powdery ash, called “particulate matter,” are an air pollutant all by themselves, because they’re small enough to slip through a body’s defenses and damage the lungs and blood vessels.

Companies that handle coal ash are supposed to contain it, which may mean covering the ash so it won’t blow away in the wind or using waterproof liners to keep the ash from soaking through the ground when it rains. But they rarely do it well, according to Lisa Evans, an attorney at the environmental nonprofit Earthjustice who specializes in hazardous waste law.

“The mismanagement of coal ash is rampant throughout the United States,” she said.

Uncontained ash

In regulatory filings, Keystone told state and local regulators it would keep its coal ash contained. The company promised to prevent the ash from blowing away by wetting ash piles with sprinklers. The company also said it would keep the ash from soaking into the ground by storing the ash on top of a waterproof concrete pad and channeling any contaminated water into a lined stormwater treatment pond.

But Jacksonville inspectors visited Keystone in 2023 and found that “a stockpile of coal ash did not have a sprinkler system set up to control unconfined particulate matter, which resulted in complaints about particulate matter leaving the site and settling on vehicles.” The city issued a $4,905 fine, and Keystone installed sprinklers.

Earlier this year, inspectors from the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) visited the site and found that Keystone was storing some coal ash on the bare dirt instead of its concrete pad, and that contaminated stormwater was “not flowing into the proper lined stormwater treatment pond” and was “being potentially discharged to surface waters or groundwater.”

So far, there are no public records that show Keystone has corrected those issues or paid a fine. Public records do show Keystone exchanged emails with state regulators in August about sampling soil and groundwater near the coal ash piles to measure pollution and schedule future inspections.

“The department identified violations at Keystone Properties and has been working collaboratively with the facility to develop a path forward and bring the site into compliance,” DEP wrote in an emailed statement. “DEP’s investigation is active and ongoing, and we are committed to enforcing Florida’s environmental regulations and addressing compliance issues appropriately.”

Coal ash spills out of a truck as it navigates Jacksonville roads. (Video courtesy of St. Johns Riverkeeper)

In the lead-up to their lawsuit, members of St. Johns Riverkeeper took photos and videos showing coal ash billowing into the river as Keystone unloaded it from barges. They’ve also filmed ash blowing out of the back of trucks driving away from the port.

“We’ve spent hours out on a boat watching as the ash comes into port,” said Rinaman. “Since we filed the lawsuit, they have improved their procedures a little bit, so it’s not as alarming. But you can still see it spilling over the sides.”

Coal ash billows before falling into the St. Johns River as the material is unloaded from a barge. (Video courtesy of St. Johns Riverkeeper)

The Keystone coal ash sits within half a mile of dozens of homes in the working-class Talleyrand and Longbranch neighborhoods. Residents say they started noticing dust drifting over their homes several years ago.

“In the past, it has gotten heavy enough that you go outside and everything has a tinge of off-white gray to it,” said Pete Corbin, who lives two blocks from the Keystone terminal and works at the Cypress Truck Lines depot, which is three blocks from Keystone.

Corbin says the dust drifts inside his home through his window air conditioning unit, and he said he believes it has contributed to his and his wife’s breathing problems.

“I don’t have the money to go to a doctor or take my wife to a doctor to get it officially diagnosed,” Corbin said. “But all of our health problems have gotten markedly worse in the last five years.”

Some local residents say they’ve noticed less ash in the air lately — especially in the months since Rinaman and November brought their lawsuit.

“It used to be very, very bad,” said Wyatt Johnson, who lives within three blocks of the ash piles and also works for Cypress Truck Lines. “There would be times where I would wake up and walk to work and say, ‘Man, it’s foggy out here.’ But it’s not actually fog. It’s just that powder hanging in the air.”

“But it’s not that bad anymore,” Johnson said. “It has definitely cooled down now that there’s some attention on it.”

A block away, however, Jeff Boone said he hadn’t noticed any change.

“Just look at everybody’s trucks and cars,” he said. “It’s over everything. It’s all over the house, the plants. It’s bad.”

Several neighbors said they’ve gotten used to washing off the fine gray powder that settles on their vehicles and seems to harden and stick, sometimes damaging their paint. Kelvin Gibson, who lives in Longbranch, said he spent $5,000 putting up a carport to protect his truck.

“I thought maybe it would cut down some of the dust,” Gibson said. “But evidently, it doesn’t.”

“I grew up here as a kid, and I’ve always been a stickler for keeping my cars clean,” Gibson added. “It wasn’t always like this.”

The ash nobody wants

Long before Keystone began storing coal ash in Jacksonville, the ash sat next to a coal power plant in Guayama, Puerto Rico, owned by the Virginia-based AES Corporation.

Since the coal plant opened in 2002, it has generated hundreds of tons of ash each day. Originally, AES stored the ash in an uncovered, unlined pile between a residential neighborhood and the sea directly above an aquifer used for drinking water. Data published by AES showed elevated levels of toxins in the local groundwater — including spikes in arsenic and chromium following Hurricane Maria in 2017. Studies from the University of Puerto Rico School of Public Health found higher rates of cancer, asthma, heart disease, and other illnesses in the area.

AES shipped some of its ash to the Dominican Republic starting in 2003. There, residents and workers similarly complained about a spike in medical problems, including miscarriages and congenital birth defects. The Dominican government sued AES, leading to a 2007 settlement in which AES agreed to remove its coal ash. (The settlement forced Dominican taxpayers, not AES, to eventually pay more than $37 million in medical damages to people who said coal ash had made them or their children sick.)

“People need to understand the risks so that they can repudiate any storage of coal ash in their area,” said Euren Cuevas-Medina, president of the Institute of Environmental Protection Attorneys in the Dominican Republic. “They’re storing poison that is toxic to their health and their water.”

Back in Puerto Rico, fierce local protests eventually prodded legislators to pass laws in 2017 and 2019 banning the disposal of coal ash on the island and prohibiting companies from storing coal ash at power plants for more than 180 days.

“We don’t have toxic landfills here, quite frankly, because there was a lot of protest,” said Ruth Santiago, a lawyer and environmental activist who fought AES’s coal ash storage. “People were outraged.”

After Puerto Rico cracked down on coal ash, AES briefly sent its ash to the JED Landfill in Osceola County in 2019 — but once again, neighbors protested and forced Osceola to stop accepting ash shipments a few months later. AES faced less resistance sending its ash to the Chesser Island Landfill near the Okefenokee Swamp in sparsely populated Folkston, Georgia. All the company needed was a port to unload its ash. The Keystone terminal in Jacksonville took the job.

It hasn’t been smooth sailing. In 2021, a cargo barge crashed at the mouth of the St. Johns River, spilling more than 9,000 tons of coal ash. Hauled before a meeting of the Jacksonville Waterways Commission on Nov. 10, 2021, Nick Primrose, chief of regulatory compliance for the Jacksonville Port Authority, clarified at the time that the publicly owned Port of Jacksonville never would have accepted coal ash shipments.

“None of Jaxport’s tenants move coal ash or coal products. We have no intention of seeking out this commodity or business entity currently or into the future, and that’s something Eric Green made very clear to me,” Primrose said, referring to the port’s CEO. “This is not in our business model now nor will it be in the future.”

But port officials can’t control Keystone, a private company that operates its own, separate terminal on the St. Johns River, where it transports and temporarily stores cement, gypsum, wood chips and other materials in addition to coal ash.

Is this ash trash?

Over the years, local and state inspectors have cited Keystone for failing to follow its own plan to contain its coal ash piles. But it wasn’t until November brought the issue to the city’s attention that officials realized Keystone never had the proper paperwork to store coal ash on-site, according to Mayor Deegan.

“This issue surfaced for us over the summer when local attorney John November led clean water litigation against Keystone for the St. Johns Riverkeeper,” Deegan said at a Nov. 17 press conference.

Deegan’s justification for blocking coal ash shipments to the Keystone Terminal hinges on defining coal ash as “solid waste.” Keystone has the necessary permits to store and transport building materials like cement and gypsum. But it doesn’t have permits to handle solid waste.

Local law requires companies to get a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity to store or transfer solid waste. Getting the certificate is a complicated process that involves reviews from multiple municipal agencies and a public hearing and vote from the Jacksonville City Council. Keystone hasn’t gone through that process, according to a Jacksonville press release.

So, is coal ash solid waste? AES markets some of its coal ash as a building material called “Agremax.” It makes Agremax by mixing and wetting coal ash, drying it into a hard slab, and crushing the slab into a dusty gravel that can be used as an ingredient in concrete. Federal regulations say coal ash can be considered a raw material that is “beneficially reused,” and not solid waste, as long as it is actually used to build something in a way that won’t allow its toxic components to leach out; otherwise, it’s waste.

Publicly available records dating to at least 2017 show that coal ash from Keystone terminal goes to a Georgia dump, which reports burying hundreds of thousands of tons of coal ash each year in its landfill. When the city found out about the old files, it cracked down, according to Phillip Perry, a spokesperson for the Jacksonville city government.

“New evidence discovered recently indicated that some or all of the coal ash was being disposed of in a landfill out of state instead of being beneficially reused, which then defines it as solid waste and subsequently requires a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity under local ordinance code,” Phillips wrote in an email. “We started the compliance process as soon as we found out it was being disposed of and that they did not have the certificate.”

Jeff Boone, who lives two blocks from the Keystone terminal, says a layer of dust builds up on his truck even within a day or two of washing it. (Photo by Nicolás Rivero) Credit: Nicolás Rivero / The Florida Trib

In a Nov. 12 email to Jacksonville officials shared with The Trib, Keystone Environmental Manager Bill Harris wrote that the company didn’t need a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity because “the Agremax coal ash material temporarily stored at Keystone does not constitute a solid waste disposal or management facility or a transfer station.”

That appears to contradict an email Harris sent less than two months earlier to Florida Department of Environmental Protection officials investigating several ways Keystone allegedly broke state law by improperly storing coal ash.

“We are working feverishly on a solid waste transfer permit application for the modified/expanded Agremax facility,” Harris wrote in the Aug. 18 email, according to public records.

No matter what happens with Keystone’s permits or the Riverkeeper lawsuit, the saga of AES’ wandering coal ash is likely to continue for several more years. Earlier this year, the Department of Energy granted AES $164.5 million to extend the life of its Guayama coal plant, and the Puerto Rican Electric Power Authority agreed to extend its contract with AES through 2032.

“PRESIDENT TRUMP IS UNLEASHING BEAUTIFUL, CLEAN COAL AFTER YEARS OF ATTACK,” Energy Department officials wrote in a June 4 statement.

Nicolás Rivero is an environmental accountability reporter at The Florida Trib based in his hometown of Miami.

Previously, he covered climate change and the environment for the Washington Post, the Miami Herald and Quartz. He has mentored reporters as a member of the Society of Environmental Journalists and as the Knight Foundation innovator-in-residence at the Florida International University Lee Caplin School of Journalism & Media. He was part of a team of reporters named a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize in National Reporting for their coverage of Hurricane Helene in 2024.

You can reach Nicolás at nicolas.rivero@floridatrib.org